How about for the base turbo engine? I have a preferred plus. I'm assuming only the S turbo will lower HP?
With the base turbo engine it does not matter what octane you use (as long as it is the recommended 87 Octane) it will not make more than 280hp.
To be honest, for me the only time I have ever seen a significant difference in real world driving between high or low octane fuels was when I lived at a high altitude (Over 5,000 feet above sea level).
For both my 2016 Lincoln MKZ that was rated for higher horsepower with higher octane fuel and the 2016 Kia Optima SXL I traded it in for (That WASN’T rated for higher horsepower with higher octane fuel) I noticed significant gains you could feel in both horsepower and gas mileage using the highest octane fuel (which in that state was only 91 octane, regular was only 85 octane).
However, in that same Kia Optima SXL at sea level I noticed no significant real world gains using Premium fuel. So, at sea level I just used regular in the Optima.
As I mentioned earlier, with only a 4 hp difference in the PHEV premium fuel doesn’t make sense, especially when they charge so much more for higher octane. Also, even if I owned an inline 6 CX-90 Turbo S think I would only use 87 Octane at sea level.